Are you picturing a backyard oasis complete with a sparkling blue pool, a grill, a patio off to the side, and everyone having a great time at your summer barbecue? Sounds like a lot of fun and a great way to bring everyone together, doesn’t it?
One thing you may be contemplating, though, is whether an above-ground or inground pool is right for your family. There are many other considerations besides costs, so let’s take a look at the pros and cons of each.
Practicality
First off, what is the most practical type of pool for your family and property? If you have a small yard, it’s probably not a good idea to take up all your open space with a large inground pool. If you have a big family with a big yard and love to entertain, an inground pool would be a wise choice.
If you’re gone a lot for work and can’t perform the regular maintenance that comes with an inground pool, this may not work for you. If you have a budding swimmer or diver in the family, an inground pool would provide much better—and safer—practice than an above-ground pool.
Additionally, if you have a ledge or rock in your yard, making way for an inground pool may be nearly impossible. In this case, an above-ground model would be a more appropriate option.
Cost
The cost is a big one. Inground pools obviously aren’t cheap. In fact, they can cost upwards of $40,000, not to mention the patio, decking, fencing, and landscaping that go along with them. An above-ground pool does not require excavation, lengthy installation, and labor costs, plus you won’t be taxed on it as a property improvement like you would an inground pool.
Appearance
Some people simply don’t like the look of an above-ground pool and would prefer the sleeker, more luxurious look of an inground one. Sometimes, above-ground pools can even bring down your home’s value—especially when they are not maintained well. If you go with an inground pool, though, you’ll shell out a lot of money on landscaping and renovations to make it look good.
Longevity
When choosing between an above-ground or inground pool, think about how long you want it to last. If you’re looking for a long-term investment that your children—and even grandchildren—can enjoy, an inground pool is the clear choice. These pools are built for durability and can serve a family for decades.
On the other hand, if you only need a pool for a few years or until you move, an above-ground option might be the better fit. These pools are more affordable, easier to install, and can even be dismantled and taken with you.
Typically, above-ground pools have a lifespan of up to 15 years for the structure, though the liner may need replacement every five years. Inground pools can last much longer, but they require consistent upkeep, such as concrete resurfacing and occasional liner replacement if applicable.
Maintenance
Both types of pools require an equal level of upkeep in terms of filtration, chemicals, and water quality. No matter which type you have, you must skim out the debris regularly, check the filter, add chemicals, and generally ensure the water looks good and healthy.
Beyond the deck and ladder, though, this is where the maintenance ends for an above-ground pool. Those are fairly simple to upkeep. Add an inground pool, and you’ve got to take care of the surrounding landscape, pressure wash the decking, maintain your patio furniture, repair cracks in the concrete, and ensure the fencing is in good shape year-round.
Return-On-Investment
Homeowners evaluating the return on investment of a swimming pool must weigh the long-term advantages each type offers. Inground pools—particularly those made from fiberglass—often increase property value due to their sleek design and lasting durability.
Above ground pools, by contrast, typically offer a lower initial investment but may not deliver the same financial benefits when it comes time to sell. The local weather and the overall aesthetics of the property also play a role in maximizing return on investment, making it important to align the pool choice with the broader appeal of the home.
Installation Speed
Speed of installation can heavily influence the right choice for a homeowner’s timeline and budget. Above ground pools generally require less construction time, allowing families to enjoy their backyard addition in a matter of days.
In contrast, inground pools involve extensive excavation, plumbing, and detailed design work that can stretch the project out for several weeks or even months. When fast project completion is a priority, above ground options provide a quicker path to enjoying a refreshing swim, all while minimizing disruptions to the lawn and everyday activities.
Year-Round Usage
Deciding which one is best based on year-round usage is another approach you can take. Inground pools, particularly those crafted from fiberglass, better accommodate heating systems, which makes them more suitable for extended seasonal enjoyment regardless of colder weather.
These pools also offer superior insulation and durability, factors that significantly enhance the user experience during cooler months. Above ground pools tend to offer a lower price point, but they often lack the structural capacity to maintain comfortable water temperatures during off-peak seasons, which may limit their functional value throughout the year.
No Matter Which You Prefer, Central Jersey Pools Has You Covered
Take heed of these pros and cons of each type of pool and call our team to start planning your installation! We install above ground and inground pools in New Jersey and are here to help your installation be seamless and stress-free. Reach out today to learn more and speak with our professional pool installers!